back to content hub
3
Min read

How can managers better support teammates struggling with personal issues?

Written By
Nausheen Eusuf
Sathya Smith | Founder of Piper

People management sounds like it’s all about being a boss: making decisions, delegating work, and getting things done.

In reality, it’s about working with human beings with the full range of emotions and problems. Sometimes those challenges can become overwhelming, impacting them not just at home but also at work.

A manager’s role includes supporting team members in a way that sets them up for success, so they can thrive both personally and professionally. In the long run, a supportive manager can determine how invested someone is in their job, and how they show up each day. 

After spending 11 years working at Google and a few more as a tech consultant, Sathya Smith knows a thing or two about being a manager. She founded Piper to help people “Be the manager you wish you had and one your employees deserve.” 

We sat down with Sathya to ask how managers can better support teammates with personal issues, create psychological safety within their teams—and still maintain healthy boundaries.

Is dealing with people’s personal issues always part of a manager’s job?

A manager’s job is to ensure that business goals are being met, and that often means helping people with whatever personal issues may be affecting their ability to do their job. If someone suddenly stops hitting their deadlines, it’s often something going on in their life, like a sick child or financial difficulties.

People don’t realise how much time goes into dealing with personal issues, even at the best of times. As a manager, you end up playing the role of therapist, parent, and friend. These so-called ‘soft skills’ are actually the hardest skills required to be a manager.

The range of issues varies tremendously. Someone who’s nervous about proposing to his girlfriend. A team member struggling with debt. A colleague with a seriously ill parent in another country. Someone having their first child and feeling anxious about becoming a parent. Employees are humans, and all sorts of things can affect their ability to focus on work.


How do you make sure your teammates feel safe opening up to you?

At Google, I was part of the Project Oxygen study where researchers tried to identify the traits of managers of high-performing teams. One of the key learnings was that high-performing managers build psychologically safe organisations. They create an environment where people feel comfortable to speak their mind, without fear of being judged.

“As a manager, you end up playing the role of therapist, parent, and friend. These so-called ‘soft skills’ are actually the hardest of skills required to be a manager."

<quote-author>Sathya Smith<quote-author><quote-company>Founder of Piper<quote-company>

Building psychological safety begins with the manager. It comes down to how you deal with issues. If someone missed a deadline, do you respond to them in a calm and collected way? If someone makes a mistake, do you rain down upon them? Or do you work with them to rectify it?

In terms of team culture—do you allow individual egos to wreak havoc? Or do you make sure that everyone has an opportunity to speak their mind and share their ideas? Even in the worst of times, it’s possible to ensure a sense of safety and comfort for your teams.

How can managers be prepared for more personal conversations?

It’s rare for things to happen very suddenly, like an unexpected death in the family. In most cases, managers will have some indication that something’s going on.

So don’t make 1-to-1s about just status updates. Get to know the individuals on your team—what drives them, what’s going on in their lives. These are data points that you’re collecting. If someone’s just found out that a parent is ill, you know that conversation is going to come up in the following weeks.

Staying in close contact is especially important with remote and hybrid teams. You’re not going to see someone coming into the office looking a little worn out. You won’t have those visual cues. So you have to be very intentional about having regular conversations on a personal level.

 

What can a manager do to support a teammate going through a tough time?

First, understand and accept that they’re going to be distracted. Don’t impose strict deadlines. Give them the time and space they need.

Second, pull in other team members. With that person’s permission, you can let the team know they’re struggling, and make sure that the workload is balanced so that things get done. Some folks might feel more comfortable opening up to their peers than their manager. So encourage peer sharing, and see if there are team members you can rely on to provide that additional support.

Finally, managers don’t have to handle everything alone. Organisations usually have resources available for employees. Reach out to People Ops or HR, and look into employee resource programmes that might help. If mental health services are available, refer them to a professional. As managers, you need to be well-informed about what your company offers so you can direct people to the right channels.

How can managers set healthy boundaries to avoid getting in too deep?

In general, people truly care about their teammates. So sometimes it’s difficult to maintain distance between yourself and the person who’s struggling. You might want to jump in right away and do whatever you can to help.

But it’s important to have the self-awareness to take a step back. If you’re stressed or preoccupied with something else, you might not be in the right headspace to listen. It’s fine to say, ‘Could you give me 20 minutes? Let me resolve the issue at hand and then give you my full attention.’

Taking a step back also gives you greater clarity. If you’re too close to the problem, it can be hard to see possible solutions. If you act too quickly, you might end up making snap decisions without understanding the full gravity of the situation.

“Managers deal with the same stresses as everyone else, while also looking after the emotional wellbeing of their teams. So I think they need a lot more help.”

<quote-author>Sathya Smith<quote-author><quote-company>Founder of Piper<quote-company>

It’s also important to take care of yourself and have a support system, such as a peer network that you can consult for potential solutions. For instance, if you’re not a parent yourself, but someone on your team is struggling with their kids, you might not know what to do. But someone else in your peer network might be able to point you to a potential resource or suggest a way forward.

What resources can companies provide to help managers support their teams?

Because managers are the first line of support for employees, companies have started putting more responsibilities onto their shoulders. Especially during the pandemic, managers have been dealing with the same stresses as everyone else while also looking after the emotional wellbeing of their teams. So I do think they need a lot more help.

First, companies need to make sure that managers get the support they need for their own wellbeing, including their mental health. As a manager, you end up absorbing a lot of stress from your team. If you’re carrying the weight of other people’s problems, it can impact you personally and professionally. I think every manager should have a therapist so they can process things and dissipate that stress.

Companies should also make sure that managers know how to partner with HR teams. In larger organisations, HR is often optimised for organisational success. But managers need to know that HR is not only for people processes, but also for people support. 

What advice would you give to a manager facing this situation for the first time?

Be patient. Accept that personal issues will come up. Accept that it’s going to impact team productivity, and it won’t get resolved overnight. Take a deep breath, and help the team.

Oliva therapist photograph

by Oliva therapist

1

2

3

4

5